Update: Since this post is so popular I thought I’d add a summary. In short, Spokeo is totally legit – I’ve been using it fairly regularly for the two years since I posted this and can say, without doubt, that Spokeo does not spam and only shows information that is already public. The only sketchy part is that it’s an automated service and some people are horrified to realize how easy it is to find and neatly summarize whatever they’ve put on this information superhighway if one has something as simple as an email address. My solution: if you feel guilty, contact them and let them know how you found them (Spokeo will do this for you, though that’s closer to spam) and if you have an issue with the superhighway, use an alias (name and email combination, using a proxy for IP anonymity if you’re especially concerned) that you never ever associate in any way with your ‘real’ identity, whatever that is online and/or off.
I saw some random mention of Spokeo somewhere in reference to online data and being careful what you post, so I had to check out the site to see just what ‘spokeo’ was. First click: privacy link. I’m not even going to consider using something of this sort if it sells data, especially my friend’s data. Spokeo promises never to do this, and while ‘never’ is a long time, everything currently seems legit, from Google searches to their site, and I used a Yahoo alias to create an account/log in/import contacts – they’ve combined the steps. Really, the whole site is almost stupid-simple to use. Kudos to Spokeo – they make it easy to interact with something that is not easy to do.
Almost instantly, people I know start appearing in the left column, with more activity and places than I would ever have guessed. From an address book I haven’t updated in at least five years – some of the addresses returning results are over a decade old. Minutes later I’m exclaiming over an old friend now having four children – she’d posted stories and pictures on MySpace…and I’m feeling a bit like a stalker.
See, I was reading about online data and the associated issues because it’s been something I’ve been thinking about. I tend to be pretty picky about how I put things online. You can find a plethora of information from social networks if you know my usual nick, but it’d be difficult to find out my name. Likewise, you can find the usual information in public records if you know my name, but it would be difficult to find things I put online.
Spokeo, also, has little instant information on me unless you know my spam address – the address I use to sign up for things. As it’s for spam, I don’t tend to give it out to anything but forms. Likewise, my personal addresses only go on paper or outgoing email. Not appearing on spokeo via an address book import is not an entirely unexpected side-effect, though it came about from a different angle: separation of identities and avoidance of spam. I have always assumed anything online is accessible to anyone, and that includes things on any computer I have hooked up to the internet.
When I find people online who do not share this assumption, and get angry that their information ended up with someone or on somewhere they didn’t want (like on Google or in some spam list) I find myself confused. This is the digital highway, is it not? You use Google, do you not? You must comprehend some of the basic functionality of the internet. But they don’t, and I’m left wondering what people would make of my use of spokeo. Everything in spokeo is public – there is no hacking going on, and it’s nothing I couldn’t have found on my own had I looked. It just makes things easier. And that, my friends, is the issue behind the issue.
Spam would be an almost non-issue if there were no bots or automation involved – if the spammers had to type in each email address, each message. On the other hand, in such a world there would be no RSS feeds. I see spokeo as somewhere in the middle right now – it has no inherent ‘evil’ because it isn’t doing anything illegal, it isn’t hacking into private data, and it isn’t doing anything I couldn’t or wouldn’t have liked to have done myself. It’s simply making it easier for me to do. The problem lies in the fact that some of the people, albeit people who would likely not mind me viewing their data, may not realize I now have access to that data.
So what did I do? I imported the rest of my contacts. As I know each of these people, and would generally either like to speak to them or don’t care to read their stuff at all, I figure I’ll take a bit of time as I find it to write something to them wherever I found them, or at whatever email address seems to be active. In this way, I don’t have to feel like a stalker and can salve my conscience while, perhaps, helping to spread the knowledge that this is, in fact, an information highway. One which I shall use as best I can, and that includes having all of my friend’s social network data on a single site.
Filed under: informal, privacy, spokeo